Pages

Showing posts with label Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Review. Show all posts

Sunday, October 3, 2010

Thoughts on: The Human Stain by Philip Roth

This morning as I slowly came to life, I finished reading "The Human Stain" by prolific American writer Philip Roth.

I've never read anything by Roth before, but I must say that reading this book was a wholly delightful experience.  Every word, scene and character is hand crafted in such a way that you are pulled into the far-reaching narrative as soon as the light turns green.  The result is a multi-faceted, sharp and profound plot that focuses on a cast of players that are as real and human as a next-door neighbour. 

The story begins with Coleman Silk, the Dean of Athena University.  His life has slowly been falling apart.  First, he is forced to resign from teaching under suspicion of racism.  During roll call of one of his classes, he comes across the same two students who never attend the class.  So he calls out "Does anyone know these people?  Do they exist or are they spooks?".  It turns out the two students whom were always absent were African Americans, and when they heard the comment, took it to be an archaic racial slur and mounted an offensive against him.  Slowly he is pushed from the university, the tides change, his wife dies from a stroke and all that rage and loneliness wells up inside of Coleman Silk.  He begins writing a book called Spooks, in the belief that it will prove that the university killed his wife.

In comes our narrator, Nathan Zuckerman.  He is a neighbour of Coleman who comes into his life abruptly one day, raving about the book, the murder of his wife and asking Zuckerman to help him with the writing.  Slowly Zuckerman befriends Coleman and in so doing discovers both the great person and the great secrets that have surrounded his life.  What ensues is a historical, lively and character-focused account of not only Silk's life, but those that came in contact with him by blood or bond.

Coleman is a compelling character, as is Zuckerman but Roth does not stop there.  Whether you are reading about Les Farley (PTSD afflicted Vietnam War Veteran, angry, failed dairy farmer and incredibly courageous and self-searching) or Delphine Roux (Parisian born, beautiful, petite and highly intellectual Athena professor who both hates and strangely loves Coleman Silk despite her better judgement), Roth brings each sliver of each person to life through his unique writing style.  You aren't just reading an overarching narrative when you read this book.  You slip into their minds, from character to character, until each slice of life, each painstakingly simple scene has fully come to realization. 

I loved it, beginning to end.  That being said, it was DENSE and took me a long time.  Never once did I feel that I was slogging, instead, I felt as if I was savouring.  On the addition of the book that I read, the front cover has a quote that reads "In American literature today, there's Philip Roth, and then there's everybody else" - Chicago Tribune.  Huge words, and I'm not well read enough to in any way ratify the statement.  However, it was an awesome (in the actual sense of the word) piece of literature, and one that will continue to develop in my mind for years to come.

Saturday, September 25, 2010

Thoughts on: Beatrice & Virgil by Yann Martel

I have finished, and had time to mull over, my most recent conquest: Beatrice & Virgil by Yann Martel. 



I originally picked up the book because I loved Life of Pi.  I read it for the first time when still in High school, which feels like eons ago.  It is one of the few books I read several (more than twice, less than twenty) times.  Sometimes when I feel like I'm going to go nuts, I like to read it in the bathtub.  Martel's tone matches the feeling of floating in water and it is altogether a spiritual experience. 

While I did not find Beatrice & Virgil as physically affecting, it was imaginative, expressive and touching.  There are 2 main characters, both named Henry.  Henry no. 1 is an author who is a very thinly veiled copy of Yann Martel himself.  He responds to a request for help from Henry no. 2 who is writing a dramatic, allegorical piece called Beatrice and Virgil. In the play, Beatrice is a donkey and Virgil is a Howler Monkey (and yes, they are a reference to The Divine Comedy).  And so, the scene is set for a story, full of self-realization and philosophical rambling.  I won't ruin it, but there is quite a twist at the end.  I should have seen it coming, but I missed the signs.  Looking back, they're definitely there.  Read closely.

Yann is a master of dialogue.  There are two levels of dialogue in the book.  The first is the dialogue between the two Henrys.  They don't really like each other, but they seem to feed off one another as creators.  There is also the dialogue between Beatrice and Virgil.  As their story is written as a play, their entire characters are created by dialogue.  Beckett and Diderot are cited as being similar the play: no action, lots of talking.  These two have an almost Rosencrantz and Guildenstern feel to them.  Beatrice and Virgil also exist outside the book, in the as taxidermy animals in Henry no. 2's shop.  The howler monkey sits on the donkey's back, just like in the play.  It's a taxidermy shop so they've been stuffed and posed.  As Henry no. 1 puts it, the shop is "a room full of adjectives, like a Victorian novel".  Add to that a miscellany of other exotic animals placed in realistic poses in perfectly recreated and dimly lit scenes of their natural habitat.  Spooky, and kind of unnerving in my eyes.

The story slowly peels back the onion of a story that is Beatrice and Virgil, mostly narrated by the old, somber and very eccentric Henry no. 2.   Overall, I thought the book was a very easy read that leaps between bizarre situations, stitching them seamlessly together through a pastiche of rhyme and reason.  It is an elegant, and at the same time oddly awkward story, probably because it is so personal in nature. 

Spoiler Alert (not really, but some people don't like to know things that happen late in the book...):  There was one oddly visceral and moving scene was one that will stick in my mind for a long time.  Throughout the story, Henry no. 1 grows close to his two animals, whom he and his wife adopt when the move to the new City at the beginning of the book.  There is a cat named Mendelssohn and a dog named Erasmus.  You get to know Erasmus a little better, because Henry no. 1 uses walking the dog as an excuse to head over to Henry no. 2's bizarre little taxidermy shop to work on the play.  Anyway, they die, suddenly and gruesomely.  Henry no. 1 has to put them down.  Erasmus gets rabies and mauls Mendelssohn, breaking his back and puncturing his back legs.  Both of them have to go.  I was flitting through the book, wondering where all this monkey description and looking for food was going and then BAM!  It made my stomach drop.  The next few pages seemed hollow.  I had to take a break.  It seems to stick out a little bit from the rest of the story, like a spider bite on a child's calf.  Don't get me wrong, it completely fits in the book.  Henry no. 2 at one point says, when explaining taxidermy, "Life and death live and die in exactly the same spot, the body.  It is from there that both babies and cancer are born.  To ignore death, then, is to ignore life".   This scene fits at the crossroads of several themes of the book.  It just caught me off guard.  I felt really bad for those little guys, much worse than I did for the characters affected in the book.

Those are pretty much my thoughts.  Beatrice and Virgil is short, sweet and has an interesting twist.  It is well worth the read and deals with some pretty heavy issues in through a looking-glass that makes them much easier to swallow. It left me with a good taste in my mouth, but I kept on asking myself if I'd seen this trick before.  Yes, I have.  Yann Martel isn't really showing off anything new.  But if the wheel ain't broken, why fix it, right?

Ta for now,

ET out